Not so long ago, the sight of a
woman in chainmail could only have served as the butt end of a joke in a
Hollywood film. But by the time scenes of Kristen Stewart in armor roll around toward
the tail end of Snow White and the
Huntsman, her metal attire is not a laughing matter at all. “You look good
in mail,” comments Chris Hemsworth’s grizzled Huntsman and, besides being a
flashy pun on the part of the all-too-clever writers, the comment rings with
sincerity. The Huntsman means no humor in pointing out Snow White’s dress; she does look good in the armor.
Directed by first-timer Rupert
Sanders and written by Evan Daugherty, John Lee Hancock, and Hossein Amini, Snow White and the Huntsman isn’t so
much a return to the darknesses of the original Grimm Brothers fairytale (moving
away from Disney’s light-hearted 1937 film, which has come to define the story
in the modern day imagination) as it is a revisionist, feminist take on the
tale, as both Disney and Grimm defined it: the helpless princess is a creature
of the past.
Kristen Stewart dons armor for her role in Snow White and the Huntsman; via altfg.com |
More today than ever before, the
archetype of the damsel in distress is an embattled figure in the modern film
landscape. Twilight’s Bella Swan
(conspicuously also played by Kristen Stewart) might be the last of a breed; the
admiring eyes of tween girls seem to have shifted to The Hunger Games’ Katniss Everdeen (Jennifer Lawrence in the recent
film adaptation) and Stewart’s incarnation of Snow White as potential role
models. Not only are these young women strong and independent, they possess the
warrior spirit, the special knack of roughhousing with the boys but escaping
the tags of either ‘tomboy’ or ‘femme fatale.’
I like to think of Hollywood’s
acceptance of something as a kind of societal measuring stick: how far have we
made it? Take, for example, Sean Penn’s Best Oscar win for his portrayal of Harvey
Milk in 2008; that acceptance into the inner Oscar circle represented an important cultural victory for gay rights in the
U.S. As the final frontier of American culture, once a movement or social
concept breaks down the battlements of Hollywood, then it’s there to stay—perhaps
even to rule. The successes seen by Katniss and Snow White—The Hunger Games owns the distinction of being the first film in
the top-grossing action films of all-time helmed by a female lead and Snow White and the Huntsman has already
grossed over $100 million in the worldwide box office—will not be isolated ones;
I suspect that we will see a parade of warrior princesses in the near cinematic
future.
~
As culturally relevant as the
film might be, the question remains of whether or not it’s any good. As it
turns out, Sanders et al have turned out a pretty decent popcorn flick. Chief
among its delights are Charlize Theron’s turn as the evil queen Ravenna and the
stunning visuals, put together by cinematographer Greig Fraser, who served as
director of photography for Jane Campion’s Keats biopic Bright Star, another film that played around in the lushness of
nature. Fraser’s eye for detail sometimes feels overwrought, but he hits the
right note in key moments, like the woodsy charm he provides the fairy paradise,
which could easily have teetered into ham-handed hokeyness.
The plot is a bit convoluted and
the characters, besides the queen and Snow White, are a little too shakily
drawn to be of any enduring interest. Both the Huntsman and William, Snow
White’s aristocratic love interest, beg for further development. All around,
the acting is no better than you’d expect from a summer blockbuster; Stewart’s
turn as Snow White is the one bright spot in the film. (Although I admit the
talent I detect in her performance might be partly due to how little the Twilight series asks of her in
comparison.) Either way, I admired how she balanced a character composed of equal
parts muted anger and wide-eyed wonder, of singleness of purpose and
self-discovery. She is both warring firebrand and sensitive caretaker. One might go so far as to say that this incarnation Snow White is even a series of paradoxes: a paragon of innocence edged with anger and
violence, a damsel in distress
who does not ask for our help.
~
Beauty, as a cultural entity, finds
itself under attack in this film—not only literally, as in the case of Charlize
Theron’s CGI-assisted facial wrinkles, but also conceptually, in terms of how humanity
chooses to understand beauty and the pursuit of its ideal. After all, every story of Snow White—no matter how
revisionist—begins with the same question: Who
is the fairest of them all? It seemed like a harmless, natural question
when I came across the story as a child (and probably still seems that way in
the recent film Mirror, Mirror), but
this film transforms the question into a much darker dialogue.
One of the film’s most successful
scenes is that in which Ravenna is speaking to the mirror on the wall, which,
it ought to be noted, has oozed off its Zildjian-cymbal surface and taken human form. However, Ravenna’s brother,
whose point-of-view is picked up as he spies on his sister from around a corner, sees
her speaking to no one; the mirror remains motionless on the wall. It is a
brief, but powerful point about the captivating power of one’s own image and
the obsessive battle that some people have with their own likenesses.
Additionally, the film implicitly
questions the notion of an ideal of
beauty. Once Ravenna asks the mirror who “the fairest” is, she enters into a
relation with the world in which beauty is a measurable commodity, in which
women can somehow be slotted onto a scale. It is, of course, a nonsensical
notion—one that you hope could only ever exist in a fairytale…except for the
fact that it doesn’t. Many people carry that kind of illogical
conceptualization of beauty with them through their everyday lives.
~
The best moment in this film is
the end. (Spoiler alert, if you somehow didn’t sense the parade of spoilers
headed your way.) Snow White is crowned queen and the court, which fills the
castle hall, looks on in joy. The film gives us close-ups of the Huntsman and
the duke’s nephew William. They both flash admiring (adoring?) glances in the
direction of Snow White. In the final shot, the camera backs down the hall’s center
aisle, away from Snow White’s throne, and out the heavy wooden doors, which close
in on us. The credits roll. Crucially, the closed door cuts us off from the
romantic entanglements of the story; the film provides Snow White with a choice, but it doesn’t make her choose. The two male suitors are left
hanging. They may or may not be chosen by Snow White. Unlike her counterpart
Bella Swan, there is a third choice
(outside of Edward and Jacob)…that being no
choice. However, that’s not the end of the door’s significance.
The most famous door closed in
the face of the audience is, of course, the door swung shut on John Wayne’s
Ethan Edwards at the end of The Searchers.
It might come off as humorous at first, but the closed door is, in fact,
weightily symbolic, serving as a reminder of the separation between the
audience and the character and vice versa. When the door closes on Wayne’s
receding back, it contextualizes an obvious statement: we can’t get out there and he can’t get in here. It seems to me that the door at
the end of Snow White and the Huntsman
serves a similar purpose.
It remains to be puzzled out,
however, who we, as the audience, represent and who Snow White, as a fairytale
character, represents. In my reading, Snow White represents a new kind of
female hero, who may or may not be separated from the rest of the world—the
rest of Hollywood in particular. I think there’s room, however, for her kind of
character on our outside. Indeed, I consider myself one among many who would like to see a world filled with
young women who choose one version of Stewart over another—the Snow White
version, of course. And who doesn’t want to be a princess?
You forgot to mention three-time Academy Award winner Colleen Atwood's outstanding costume design. Ravenna's costumes seemed to have just stepped off of an Alexander McQueen catwalk. By far one of the strongest assets of the film. Gawd Pueblo, how could you have let that one slip?! ;)
ReplyDeleteYou make a fair point, NAKS. Unfortunately, I find usually myself ill-equipped to critically assess issues like choreography (in the case of this film, battle choreography), make-up, and costume design, so I'm glad you step in here to make an amendment to my review. With a little revisitation to the film's visuals, I can readily admit that the costume choices in this film were fantastic.
DeleteFortunately or unfortunately, I tend to treat issues like make-up and costume as a given in a good film. I think (to some degree) it's a measure of a costume designer's success if we don't 'notice' the costume; the costume choices in "Snow White" were exactly what I expected them to be. They were perfect because they fit the film; they were neither under-cooked nor were they distastefully overdone (think several of Tim Burton's films).
That said, my oversight of costume design does present a problem, but, importantly, it points to the fact that Colleen Atwood won this battle. In some strange way, it ought to be a measure of her success that the issue of costumes didn't even cross my mind in thinking about the film. Everything that the characters wore simply made sense.
I sense the rumblings of a guest post addressing costume issues in recent films. I'm kind of dying to hear more about them, actually. Let me know...
Cheers,
Taylor
P.S. I deleted the original comment because I fear that I cannot lash out at Tim Burton without a little defense at the end. After all, some will fairly argue that the POINT is exactly how distasteful his (well, those of his designers...) costume choices are, but I still feel like they exasperate the viewer's patience just a bit...
I just wrote a kick ass answer but internet decided not to post it. It went something like this ...
ReplyDeleteFunny that you mention that - Colleen Atwood created the costumes in numerous Tim Burton films. Namely, Edward Scissorhands, Mars Attacks, Big Fish, Sleepy Hollow, Ed Wood, Planet of the Apes, Sweeney Todd, Alice in Wonderland and the recent Dark Shadows, just to name a few. Also, don't feel too bad about putting your thoughts against Burton's decisions on this blog - he's a big boy and can probably take your criticism.
Nevertheless, I want to bring your attention to a short featurette that will give you a glimpse of the meticulous detail and the stunning creativity of Atwood's phenomenal craft. I hope this brings awareness to the amount of work and thought that goes into every decision, and how it influences the story:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4N1r9EVgcjU
On another note,
I (somewhat) agree with your "The Searchers" closing door reference. However, I want to bring to your attention the "NeverEnding Story" reference. KStew and her horse had the SAME scene that Atreyu and Artax had in the 1984 German-American production.
Only, Atreyu made me cry.
Granted, I was 7. But still, NeverEnding Story - heavy shit.
-For those unfortunate souls who never saw NeverEnding Story of can't remember this iconic scene, feast:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y688upqmRXo
Always a pleasure Pueblo.
Love and skittles,
NAKS